This is Froggy's TypePad Profile.
Join TypePad and start following Froggy's activity
Join Now!
Already a member? Sign In
Froggy
Recent Activity
That is about as sad a cry out for attention as I have ever witnessed. I'm afraid she won't be spending much more time with the friends and family that are already ignoring her going forward.
Toggle Commented May 7, 2013 on What the hell is wrong with you?! at BLACKFIVE
1 reply
I predict that this will be a total nothingburger. Those of you believing that this is the millstone that gets hung around Obama/Clinton's neck are going to be very disappointed...as usual. None of these things ever goes anywhere and even if there was something there, the media will completely ignore it until it goes away. I have completely stepped off the politics train since the election and now I can see the rollercoaster of emotions that Fox and the rest of the conservative media has everybody on. I have accepted that things are what they are and there isn't a force on Earth powerful enough to change it. Just like you don't watch the fatuous, lying gasbag liberals on their channels, don't put money in the pockets of the conservatives who are getting paid to spin you into a frenzy thinking we'll get payback or our country back. We won't get either. Standby to standby.
1 reply
Don't kid yourself that this is Obama's fault. It is our fucking fault. Obama is who he is. Our institutions have taken on lives of their own anyway. Nobody is in charge anymore, there is only institutional inertia and nothing more. Republicans are just as weak and untrustworthy as anyone. It's all a career field now. Nobody wants to fix anything, they just want their check and pension and their perks. There is no accountability and there hasn't been for a long time and there won't be any in the future. People need to wake the fuck up and realize that it is you and the System. If you have the ability to make it outside of the System, great, do that. If not, work the System as best you can and take care of your family. While everybody is busy pointing fingers at each other and worrying about the latest slight or bad decision or whatever, get your shit done. Don't waste your time arguing about how things ought to be, that ship has sailed. It is what it is and it won't get better. Get good at something people need and collect on that. Or don't. Those are the only choices left. What was it that Timothy Leary said? "Turn on, tune in, and drop out." How about, "Turn off, tune out, and drop in." Make something happen on your own, or be content with what happens to you. Anything else is wasting effort.
Toggle Commented Apr 16, 2013 on Explosions at the Boston Marathon at BLACKFIVE
1 reply
This is what happens when you don't finish the job. We have been dicking around with these people for going on 12 years now and frankly I'm surprised it took this long for these types of events to start happening. We should have made an example out of somebody after 9/11 and just left a smoldering glass parking lot somewhere with no Marshall Plan to rebuild it. We are weak, and weakness attracts aggression. I have to admit I'm having trouble giving too much of a shit about this at this point. We are incapable of solving our problems in this country anymore and I don't have any faith that this and a whole host of other problems (economic, moral/spiritual, social) will ever be solved the way this country has evolved. Why do you think end of the world/zombie tv and movies are all the rage? There is a collective sense that we are tapped out and have no initiative let alone a plan to unfuck the SITUATION such as it is. I frankly have no stomach for all of the political posturing that people like to blame this on either. You can't say with a straight face that this country would be better off with douchebag A or douchebag B and his party running the show. We ran this thing into a ditch as a nation and there are not enough people who give a fuck to deal with it, and there won't be going forward. So standby for heavy rolls.
Toggle Commented Apr 16, 2013 on Explosions at the Boston Marathon at BLACKFIVE
1 reply
Another film that should not have been made. Murph may have received the CMH, but he got it for browbeating a new TU commander into launching a mission he was unprepared to lead (as a new guy with two more new guys plus Lutrell), deciding against killing the man who subsequently informed the enemy of his location, and then calling in a QRF that got shot down killing everyone aboard. While I'm sure he didn't intend for all this to happen, it did. For the life of me I can't understand why you award someone the CMH for this abortion, but they did.
Toggle Commented Mar 20, 2013 on Murph The Protector at BLACKFIVE
1 reply
Concur on many points, but especially with respect to Iraqi Christians. No question that they have been the biggest losers in all of this and will continue to be. That turned out to be a straight up genocide that nobody talks about. It will happen in Syria as well once Assad falls. Like Saddam, Assad looked after (or at least didn't persecute) the Christians and they have paid a heavy price for that affiliation already. Once Assad is out, they will all have to flee to Lebanon or be massacred like what happened in Iraq. Lebanon is the last place where a Christian arab can worship openly in an arab society. If it falls, there is nowhere for them in the arab world.
1 reply
In my opinion the Iraq War on balance was a mistake. We may have "won" it in a certain way, but a cost-benefit analysis would prove that we didn't get much for what we gave up. I was part of the Surge and I'm very glad to have been. I enjoyed my deployment immensely, but then I'm fully intact, had an amazing role, and got recognized for it. For me, personally, it was easily one of the greatest experiences of my life, but undertaking a war isn't about me or any individual person. I wanted to go to Iraq because it was the "unwanted" war at the time and I proudly tell people now that have a problem with it to suck it and point out that they are punks for not having had the sac to roger up for the country. Undoubtedly Iran has benefited from the Iraq War, and that should have been obvious at the time to people who should have known better. Also, Shinseki was right to point out that we completely undermanned that invasion and couldn't adequately control the country with what we brought in there. It goes without saying that Bremer's decision to disband the Iraqi military and Baath Party was the single most terrible decision of the entire conflict and certainly cost thousands of US lives in the resulting chaos. He should be strung up for that one. The Bush administration had no inkling of the internal religious conflicts that existed there prior to the invasion and was very slow to figure out how to address them. In fact they never did. It was people on the ground in the West that figured it out in 05-06. When dealing with the Middle East and muslims, there really are no good guys. They are all essentially backstabbing scumbags who will turn on you as soon as it becomes expedient. I witnessed this very closely in the West with 2 Sheiks. One you have all heard of who was assassinated by his brother once he sensed that the former's utility had played out. The real story on this Sheik's death has never come out, as it was expedient for us to go along with his brother's deception, but someday it may. Whenever you think our politics are fucked up, check yourself, because those people are absolute savages.
1 reply
I don't think its necessarily right to castigate a guy for something he didn't do (award himself), and I would expect that he feels some level of embarrassment over it. My BSMV was being considered for upgrade to SS, and I'm glad I didn't get it. It would have been very weird to put that on given the circumstances, but I am very grateful for the recognition that the BSMV signifies. I don't know that I would have turned down the SS though. It's a difficult subject and there are arguments on both sides. In the end, the community that you are a part of dictates the norms and standards for these awards and an NSW BSMV is very meaningful in inter-service terms where a BSM for an USAF Chaplain not so much.
1 reply
You can say that of USAF pilots landing on the ground, but there is a major difference with respect to USN/USMC guys coming off the carrier. For any pilots, to be strapped into a metal box for 8 hours and several re-fuelings pissing in a bottle is somewhat different than putting a drone on autopilot while to take a dump down the hallway.
Toggle Commented Feb 20, 2013 on So "badass" at BLACKFIVE
1 reply
This probably needs to happen. Cut everything. The shit has gotten out of control. No more sacred cows. The military has wasted so much money in the past 12 years it makes me want to vomit. Military pay is very competitive right now, so I really don't see the problem.
1 reply
FISA Court. The NCA could submit a classified death warrant request, and the FISA Court members could chew on it, ask some questions, and then sign off. That would work perfectly fine for me. As it is, extrajudicial executions by Executive Order of AMCITS is unsat.
1 reply
I was definitely against the al Awlaki hit at the time for the same reasons UJ is talking about. There needs to be a check and balance on this shit. Perhaps the FISA Court?
1 reply
Looks like that PJ is sweeping the casualty with his muzzle there. Way to go Air Force.
Toggle Commented Jan 29, 2013 on Photo: Djibouti Desert Drill at BLACKFIVE
1 reply
Well, back in the day when I was a Marine, your default MOS was infantry. If you came in and didn't pick something (general enlistment) you got sent to the infantry. If you didn't qualify for what you did pick or didn't complete the training... infantry. Before me, if you got drafted... infantry. I don't know how the Army works, but it seems incredible that you have to volunteer for the infantry. I have no doubt that many guys would volunteer for it, but I'm surprised to hear that there is basically a waiting list? I would think there would be a waiting list for tank gunner and aircraft mechanic, but not for that. Aren't there people that enlist and when asked what they want to do, say, "Whatever you need, just put me in coach,"?
1 reply
First of all and as per usual, you are going full retard on an important issue. Second of all, training standards MUST be changed for this work for the people who dreamed it up. They simply cannot have massive female attrition during these training courses or it will look bad and they won't have the opportunity to bask in the unearned glory of the nitwit broads that sign on for this. Third, women in the military for the most part do not want this. That will become abundantly clear the next time a major overseas contingency operation including women is launched. Probably sooner as most of our female servicemembers are not down for this. Finally, I hope that the standards are altered and that women are involuntarily assigned to these units at the same rate and proportion men are. Admittedly, I don't know much about how that works as NSW is all volunteer, but not everybody gets to be military journalist or whatever pogue job people might like. Most guys are sent off or request to be in these combat arms type units in some capacity or another. If these women want to be equal, then be fucking equal.
Toggle Commented Jan 24, 2013 on Women in Combat at BLACKFIVE
1 reply
As a frogman, my entire career path is completely voluntary and I could leave NSW at any time due to the nature of the business. Way back when I was a Marine in the late 80's, if you didn't specifically pick something or if you weren't intellectually qualified for what you did pick, you ended up in the infantry. In a scenario where a draft is initiated, I would expect the majority of draftees to face such a situation. I have to disagree with LTSO here and out of an abundance of equality and fairness DEMAND that women are involuntarily assigned to combat arms at the same rate and proportion as men are. Fuck all of this "women get to choose combat arms" bullshit. If you are in the service, you're going where you are told and if you don't like it, your enlistment will be up in 3 1/2 years so you're good. There WILL be a double standard going forward as the absence of one would create massive attrition and therefore humiliation for advocates of this policy. Equality. I'm pretty sure that 99% of the women in the military are not particularly interested in combat as a primary job. The sweet irony of this is that nothing will drive more women from the military than this policy. We will see enlistment rates in the Army and Marine Corps drop like a rock. The unfortunate by product of that reality is that the Air Force and to a large extent the Navy (excepting NSW) will essentially become bitch factories as enlistment of women in those non-ground combat focused services begin to attract more females subsequently crowding dudes out. The only real "winners" here are the female political activists who will be free to bask in the unearned "glory" that a few crossfit dykes here and there may afford them. So congratulations America! nb: I am a crossfitter so no disrespect. I am regularly impressed by women who are knocking out pullups, snatches, and thrusters like rock stars every morning at my gym. That's the kind of fitness level required to actually hang.
1 reply
Sung to the tune of "O Christmas Tree" Jarheads drowning in the waves, It's UDT that always saves, Although they say there first ashore, UDT's been there before. And other things that they can't do, It's UDT that pulls them through, Oh leathernecks on bended knee, Come kiss the ass of UDT! Merry Christmas Continue reading
Posted Dec 23, 2012 at BLACKFIVE
Exactly correct. People love seeing our troops carrying a gun and standing in front of stuff overseas, they won't like seeing that here. It might make their tummys upset. Better to just ban all guns and wait for the peace and love to follow.
Toggle Commented Dec 19, 2012 on I got an idea and it employs Vets!! at BLACKFIVE
1 reply
There is no quibbling with the power of BPD. BPD patients in a manic phase can be the most dangerous people on this planet. I have personally witnessed what a 6-9, 320 semi pro football player in a manic phase can do to a locked psych unit. Let's put it this way, its not locked for him. Can you say major renovations? After trashing the unit with one of those sliding scales that you use to measure height and weight, he busted through a massive security door at full speed and ran out onto the Highway where SDPD hit him with two tasers and a K9 on each arm which he swung around like a couple of hamsters. It took 6 cops with billy clubs and 4 sets of handcuffs to get him under control. He's lucky he wasn't shot. Shockingly, he returned to our unit 3 days later and much calmer and I had the chance to interview him. The point is that these people are perpetually spring loaded and it is difficult to know when they are about to go off. I also admitted a man who was legitimately demon possessed and it was one of the most horrifying times of my life. On the surface, he was a normal looking 40 something man and when I asked him is birth date for the admission form he told me some date in the 1600s. After that, a roar began to build deep from within him the sound of which was literally the most terrifying sound that I have ever heard. It started out as a low grumble and as it reached a crescendo that sounded like a monster from another planet, I quickly slipped out of the room and locked the door behind me. He made this sound continuously without resting to breathe for several minutes and the entire unit could hear this man. He was gone a few days later and I have no idea what became of him, but whatever was inside him could have easily killed a room full of school children.
Toggle Commented Dec 18, 2012 on Gun Control vs. Teh Crazy at BLACKFIVE
1 reply
Make no mistake, we are not talking about Internet loners or kids on ADHD meds. We are talking about severely emotionally disturbed individuals who either have profound personality disorders or who have psychotic episodes due to schizophrenia or bipolar disorder. These people are born broken in the same way that that a kid born with cerebral palsy is. They cannot be cured only managed and cared for. They may improve for a period of time, but they will never be able to join society as a productive member. Their minds are diseased just like somebody with a faulty heart valve is except there's no surgery that can fix them. We owe them and ourselves to place them in an appropriate and caring environment and not to simply take the easy away out and try to ban guns.
Toggle Commented Dec 18, 2012 on Gun Control vs. Teh Crazy at BLACKFIVE
1 reply
Let me first stipulate and make plain that gun control has no role in preventing mass shootings like the ones in CT or CO. I understand that people want to debate that, but allow me to make a few points regarding the mental health situation in the US or at least in CA. After leaving active duty with tons of medical training and few other marketable skills, I worked at two mental hospitals on their locked units and with the San Diego PD Homeless Outreach Team focusing on evaluating people for involuntary psychiatric commitment under CA Code 5150. 5150 essentially states that a person can be involuntarily committed to a psychiatric facility for 72 hours if they are a danger to themselves or others or can be considered "gravely disabled". I'm no psychiatrist, but I have extensive knowledge of abnormal behavior and the way that the mentally ill interact with our legal system. Back in the 1960s the federal government and some of the States began to rethink policies concerning the chronically mentally ill in the US. A combination of budget cuts and a strong "patient rights" movement conspired to change the way we looked at the mentally ill. The patient rights groups argued that these people were being systematically denied civil rights to make their own decisions (which is true), but after "freeing" them and patting themselves on the back, they didn't do anything much to address the subsequent issues that have obviously arisen. Ostensibly there are are series of welfare/safety net programs to support the indigent, but in the case of the mentally ill, they are incapable of comprehending their own needs and advocating on their own behalf. Conservatorship is a mechanism by which a court appoints someone to make health, financial, and other decisions for an incompetent adult. The idea behind it is great, but there are powerful "patient advocate" groups and court appointed defense counsels whose mission it is to defeat these procedings especially when the conservatee's family is attempting to institute this remedy. The result of this struggle probably accounts for more than 50% of the US homeless population today. While full time welfare queens are out there gaming the system for every nickel, these mentally ill folk are left to rot in their own filth on sidewalks across America. It takes a while for them to make it to the sidewalk though. Before that happens, their families are often tormented and threatened by their kin for years on end with nary an option aside for short stints in County Mental Health or County Jail. Psychosis and paranoia are powerful threats to the families of the mentally ill and few are equipped physically, psychologically, or financially to address them. After years of difficulty, altercations, threats, and public humiliation these families tend to exhaust their compassion for these people and they are cut loose on to the streets for people like me on the HOT Team to deal with. There is tremendous power in psychosis because it lacks any acknowledgement of itself, has no conscience, no limitations, and it has a florid imagination, foolproof internal defense mechanisms and great physical strength owing to its "fight or flight" adrenaline charged nature. These people truly are to be pitied and cared for by our society. They can never hold a job, keep a schedule, manage their finances, properly nourish themselves, or maintain healthy relationships as their own minds conspire against them. Make no mistake, this is a medical/chemical condition and not a choice. In fact, the key feature of psychosis is avoidance of the medications that can reduce their delusions, hallucinations, and paranoia. Their internal voices fiercely argue against treatment as they somehow understand that it would kill the symptoms that they exist to produce. We have had the gun control discussion in this country for many years and clearly the American people recognize the importance of the Second Amendment. That ship has sailed. The conversation we need to have is about what we are not doing to address our mental health system. There are precious few beds in long term facilities and County facilities and prisons are constantly overflowing. Seeing the rank injustice of professional welfare scammers running up a tab on my tax bill while these utterly helpless people are left in a state of near constant panic, confusion, and paranoia ought to be a call to action especially now. Let's kick these freeloading bums of the teet and help the desperate few among us who truly cannot care for themselves. Continue reading
Posted Dec 17, 2012 at BLACKFIVE
13
I wish I had enough extra time on my hands to worry about such a critical issue.
Toggle Commented Dec 12, 2012 on The Chesty Puller Monument at BLACKFIVE
1 reply
To me if you are some NGO do-gooder working downrange you get what you get. Last time this happened, it was a Brit female that we went in for and she got accidentally fragged and KIA. Everybody in the UK was up in arms about it as if the guy who threw the grenade did it for shits and giggles. When you are operating in Indian country unarmed you are explicitly accepting a risk that you might get rolled up and there should be no expectation that somebody is coming for you. Ground Branch guys certainly understand that they are in the wind if their missions go sideways and that they are not likely to get rescued let alone acknowledged to be on a covert operation, so its not like there isn't a precedent. As to why ST6, they and CAG are the only units that do hasty Hostage Rescue operations (as this apparently was) since their training and resources are far above other unit's capabilities. In any case, what difference would it make if this were a White SOF unit as opposed to an SMU? A SOF guy and a conventional guy are both valuable, the only difference is a matter of capability. The 82nd Abn doesn't have this capability so they would never get this mission. The guys at ST6 are always going to want to do these missions just on general principle, but their leadership has a responsibility to task them with things that are of national strategic significance. This operation does not qualify. If you want to be a do gooder NGO person, then fine, be one. They lose points in my estimation for hedging their bets and expecting rescues like this though. Be prepared to give your life for your cause, just like our servicemembers are.
1 reply
The problem with this argument is that in order for it to be true, the whole incident would never have been possible in all likelihood. You can't just insert a SOF element into a foreign city under fire in 3 hours. That is unless you had them on standby offshore with helos gassed up and armed, some kind of rudimentary plan, and positive comms with the consulate. If you had all that, it would indicate that you were already prepared for something to happen and that you would have been in a position to handle it accordingly. That clearly is not the situation here. This would have taken considerable pre planning, like having CH-47's (Army type) flying off of an LHA or Carrier with legit armored vehicles. The idea that we would drop 10-20 SOF operators into a foreign city that we have just lost all of our "safe areas" in on foot is fucking absurd. Shits not going to happen. What about MEDEVAC? Exfil? You can't just throw a bunch of dudes out of a C130 over Libya in 3 hours. The dudes with that kind of capability would take like 24 hours (See Pirate Sniper shot mission) to be on station. Even the pilot team guys out of HOA took 8 hours to get to the Bainbridge. So it ain't all that easy to pull this off and frankly impossible if you aren't ready for it to go down at all, which these idiots weren't.
1 reply
I'm not sure that Lutrell is prepared to concede that the mission should not have happened especially since it cost him three close friends and a horrifying experience of his own. SEALs are not in the business of kicking our people when they are down either thus the lack of scrutiny on Red Wings. One of the reasons why I don't feel the need to read these books is because I am typically hearing these stories from primary sources anyway and through that channel I am also receiving a more unvarnished picture. You are reading somebody's book and you should expect a more "focused" perspective. Additionally, my criticisms of the bin Laden book has little to do with the content and more to do with the fact that he violated what you might describe as our cultural norms.
1 reply