This is Kantor57's Typepad Profile.
Join Typepad and start following Kantor57's activity
Join Now!
Already a member? Sign In
Kantor57
Recent Activity
@Spike I am not (and I cannot be) an expert of the specific features of that BRT and so I have to bow to your judgement.. However I was responding to a specific point of @Goosoid; and I maintain that leaving people behind with 2/3 minutes headways is not a measure of success, but rather of bad progemming...
1 reply
@Goosoid " the only problem is that it is working so well, people are being left behind at stops by full buses. Buses are running at 2-3 minute intervals at peak times." and this simply means that BRT was a wrong choice to start with; if with 2-3 minutes headways you leave people behind you have a big problem of capacity... a problem that can only be solved with light rail (longer trains...)
1 reply
My impression is that BRT is a good third world solution for third world countries; not so good elsewhere because of labor cost and politics. In general BRT is trying to fit a square peg in a round hole: busses are very good at being busses (more flexibility of the routes, more capability of going around obstacles and so on..) and rail is very good at being rail (speed, capacity and much more confort).
1 reply
@Jarrett I do appreciate your position; you believe that a professional in your field should present the advantages of a good transit grid, without emphasizing the mean of transportation. I respect that and I believe that it should be the standard, in an ideal world. Unfortunately we do not live in an ideal world; we live in world riddled with preconceptions, personal and/or political interests and general stupidity. And we cannot escape from that reality.
1 reply
Can good transit stimulate development? That's a clear rhetorical question to which the answer is: of course yes! But then we have to find an agreement on what "good" means, relative to transit. Jarrett Walker has his answer to that question, that does not coincide with mine. He thinks that "frequency is freedom" irregardless of the mean, but I beg to differ. And then we're back to the usual argument "rail vs. bus" that has been discussed at length here and elsewhere...
1 reply
I've read most of it and it is the usual meme "BRT is about 1/3 cheaper than a tramway (unless you need real capacity) and it can be as nice as a tramway (unless you want to integrate it in a dense urban environment) and people might like it almost as a tramway (unless they have already the real thing around)" I wasn't buying it the first time I heard it and I am not buying it now
1 reply
Kantor57 is now following The Typepad Team
May 26, 2012