This is Paul Levy's Typepad Profile.
Join Typepad and start following Paul Levy's activity
Join Now!
Already a member? Sign In
Paul Levy
Cyberlitigator on free speech issues at Public Citizen
Recent Activity
by Paul Alan Levy This morning we filed a motion for leave to intervene in the proceeding, now assigned to Chief Judge Robert Morin of the Superior Court for the District of Columbia, in which DreamHost has been opposing the... Continue reading
Posted 2 days ago at CL&P Blog
by Paul Alan Levy On Friday morning, a panel at the annual meeting in New York of the Association of Professional Responsibility Lawyers will be discussing an issue dear to the heart of blawgers who discuss subjects that make powerful... Continue reading
Posted Aug 9, 2017 at CL&P Blog
by Paul Alan Levy This past spring, Twitter garnered significant attention, and widespread praise, for a lawsuit it brought against the Trump Administration this past spring to block enforcement of an administrative summons seeking to identify the owners of a... Continue reading
Posted Jul 26, 2017 at CL&P Blog
by Paul Alan Levy Two decisions were issued late yesterday in cases involving the procedures for adjudicating subpoenas seeking to identify anonymous Internet speakers who are accused of actionable speech. An appeals court in California embraced most elements of the... Continue reading
Posted Jul 20, 2017 at CL&P Blog
by Paul Alan Levy The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has issued an order signed only by the Clerk declaring that a significant free speech issue bearing on the rights of anonymous Internet users will be... Continue reading
Posted Jul 19, 2017 at CL&P Blog
by Paul Alan Levy An important appeal is pending in the District of Columbia Court of Appeals – the highest appellate court in D.C. The federal government served D.C. warrants on Facebook, demanding access to the entirety of 90 days... Continue reading
Posted Jun 30, 2017 at CL&P Blog
by Paul Alan Levy Ever since Eugene Volokh and I started writing last year about the phenomenon of “fake defamation litigation” — lawsuits filed to suppress online criticism while ensuring that the person whose speech is to be suppressed never... Continue reading
Posted Jun 23, 2017 at CL&P Blog
This article at Think Progress points to some worrisome waivers in the terms of service for the DNA testing service at argues in response that the some of the concerns are overstated but that in any event it... Continue reading
Posted May 24, 2017 at CL&P Blog
by Paul Alan Levy Pursuant to the settlement in Smith v Garcia and Chief Judge Smith's ensuing order in that case, counsel for Richart Ruddie arranged to have a motion filed in the names of Bradley Smith and his debt... Continue reading
Posted May 12, 2017 at CL&P Blog
by Paul Alan Levy Last year I discussed an attorney fee application that I prepared on behalf of a small company making canvas totes that poke fun of such high-fashion royalty as Louis Vuitton by scrawling the words “My Other... Continue reading
Posted Apr 10, 2017 at CL&P Blog
by Paul Alan Levy With the signature of Governor Terry McAuliffe having been added last week, Virginia has adopted a modest improvement to its very narrow anti-SLAPP statute. The new law, SB 1413, is not nearly as strong as in... Continue reading
Posted Mar 20, 2017 at CL&P Blog
by Paul Alan Levy Over the past few months, I have reported, to some extent jointly with Eugene Volokh, on a purportedly pro se lawsuit filed in the United States District Court for the District of Rhode Island. Brought against... Continue reading
Posted Mar 14, 2017 at CL&P Blog
by Paul Alan Levy The Trans-Atlantic Consumer Dialogue, a coalition of nearly 100 consumer organizations on both sides of the Atlantic, will be holding its annual meeting in DC from March 19 to March 21, including a public forum on... Continue reading
Posted Mar 1, 2017 at CL&P Blog
Two factoids in the article that struck me when I read it yesterday morning appear in these sentences. "The arbitration was first filed in 2008 . . . . The class-action case, still unresolved, now includes One of the original women who brought the case, those lawyers said, died in 2014 as proceedings crawled on without resolution." So arbitration, touted as providing a fast alternative to the all-too-cumbersome courts, can take even longer. This arbitration proceeding is now into its NINTH year.
Nicely written, John, other than that weird graf in the middle that you put in quotation marks and then identify YOURSELF as the person quoted.
A fundamentally bad idea, in my opinion. Even "dishonest, lying scum" have First Amendment rights
by Paul Alan Levy i-Geniuses is a Houston company that repairs Apple products; it especially touts its ability to repair computers suffering from liquid damage on a fast turnaround schedule. A number of former customers have expressed concerns about the... Continue reading
Posted Jan 30, 2017 at CL&P Blog
Charles Harder says in his comment that I "asked [him] to provide [me] information for [my] piece" and complains that I did not provide a link to his client's web site. This is the request I sent him (to which he replied by sending me a link to his client's propaganda web site, which I thought irrelevant to my questions). From: Paul Alan Levy Sent: Wednesday, January 25, 2017 3:29 PM To: '' Subject: Your demand letter to Diaspora I am working on a piece about your demand letter to Diaspora on behalf of the fellow who claims to have invented email and has a history of suing people who dispute that claim. I am wondering if you would answer some questions. What is the basis for your claim that Diaspora, as the host of user comments that criticize your client, is legally liable under Massachusetts law for intentional infliction of emotional distress, based I gather on the intent of the user who posted the comments, and subject to Massachusetts law “remedies [that] include monetary damages, punitive damages, and preliminary and permanent injunctive relief?” Is there some reason why section 230 immunity does not apply? As I read your letter, you also claim that Diaspora, the host of the comments, is subject to “substantial monetary damages and punitive damages” under a libel theory under Massachusetts law. Have I misunderstood your claim? And again, what is the basis for avoiding section 230 immunity?. Finally, I am also curious about your contention that, because your letter is subject to copyright protection, publication is prohibited. Are you contending that publication would constitute infringement? Have you registered the copyright?
by Paul Alan Levy Shiva Ayyadurai is a computer scientist who insists that it was he who, as a child prodigy, invented email. Although his claim has been widely derided by many of the major figures who were party to... Continue reading
Posted Jan 26, 2017 at CL&P Blog
by Paul Alan Levy During the 2016 election cycle, the slogan “Keep America Great” emerged as a counterweight to the Make America Great Again slogan on which candidate Donald Trump was campaigning. A fellow named Andreas Mueller tried to capitalize... Continue reading
Posted Jan 24, 2017 at CL&P Blog
Responding to widespread complaints from its consuming public, including some articles on this blog as well as a consumer gripe site, DC United has withdrawn a demand that its season ticket holders sign away the right to talk about the... Continue reading
Posted Jan 17, 2017 at CL&P Blog
by Paul Alan Levy Could Donald Trump, who is notorious for his intolerance of public criticism, and who has promised to "open up the libel laws," evade the First Amendment and section 230 stricture on defamation claims by repackaging them... Continue reading
Posted Dec 20, 2016 at CL&P Blog
by Paul Alan Levy An announcement from the White House today listed the Consumer Review Fairness Act as one of several bills that President Obama signed into law yesterday. Here is my public statement on the development. And today I... Continue reading
Posted Dec 15, 2016 at CL&P Blog
by Paul Alan Levy The Michigan Court of Appeals issued a decision today on the standards for deciding whether a plaintiff claiming to have been wronged by anonymous (or pseudonymous) online speech may compel the host of that speech to... Continue reading
Posted Dec 7, 2016 at CL&P Blog
Max, there has been no change in the language. I did my renewal, and my credit card was paid in full, before they came up with this cockeyed language. My guess is that they are not going to want to give me my $2000 back (I have four season seats) for not signing the agreement. Note that there is a new blog post on this subject, and a new "protest web site" addressed to it