This is Dennis Nelson's Typepad Profile.
Join Typepad and start following Dennis Nelson's activity
Dennis Nelson
Recent Activity
At the top of our list is to have the drawing list also show what sheets were issued with different revisions.
The Drawing List Neighborhood
Often when looking at a feature or enhancement there is opportunity to make some changes "while in the neighborhood". Imagine a feature as a comet. When it's close to earth it gets a lot of attention - cameras, probes, discussion ect. - but then it is back to obscurity until it returns again....
Here is a quick run down of the some of the issues that we encountered. We are a structural engineering firm and we tried to use the copy monitor functions, on a 28 story concrete constructed condo tower. The arch had started the model so we thought it would be a good test. We copy monitored the grids, levels and slabs. We thought it would be nice not to remodel all the slabs since the arch was going to own or control them. I will say that levels and grids worked great. We had serious issues with the slabs though.
1. Since it was early DD every time we got a new model the list of changes was mile long. It took almost a day to go through the list of changes. Which is partly because of the way the dialog box is organized and interacts with the model. It would be nice to have the ability to sort the list with more options. For slabs it would be nice to have them listed by level. This way I could see each slab element that changed on a given floor, and also quickly isolate elements that are close to each other. Also the interaction from the dialog box and the model is clumsy and needs to be improved. If you are going to have a tool like this you need be able to find and isolate elements quickly in the model. You also need the ability to work in the model and without having to close down the dialog box, because when things change you want to see how that change will affect the element surrounding it. I think this is a dialog box that needs to have the ability to dock some where. You should be able to highlight or select elements form the list and quickly isolates those elements in the model. Also the “show element always seems to find the most obscure view that the element is shown in. I think it should search through the views on a sheet first.
2. If the architect deletes a slab and puts a new one in its place. You will get a message that an element was deleted, but you won’t get an message saying that a new element has been put it the model and do you want to copy monitor that element.
3. Point and line slopes didn’t copy monitor slab came in flat in our model even though arch had sloped them.
4. We had some trouble with openings in slabs not getting moved or showing up at all even though they were clearing in different spots in the models. It could have something to due with #2 but I didn’t research it to much because this was the last straw, and decided to scrap the copy monitor and just linked the arch slab into our model.
Copy/Monitor Documentation
The Autodesk BIM User Assistance Team is continuing work to enhance the online help. In this example, they are revising the Copy/Monitor documentation. Below is a version tailored for Revit Architecture (If you prefer a MEP or Structure version let me know). _erik Revit Architecture Copy Monit...
I think it's great that Autodesk is looking for feed back, but I agree 100% why revamp the documentation when that fact is the tools itself needs to revamped. We don't use copy monitor because it's not worth the pain and in some instances just doesn't work. Fix the tool then work on the documentation.
Copy/Monitor Documentation
The Autodesk BIM User Assistance Team is continuing work to enhance the online help. In this example, they are revising the Copy/Monitor documentation. Below is a version tailored for Revit Architecture (If you prefer a MEP or Structure version let me know). _erik Revit Architecture Copy Monit...
A couple things you describe what the different wall functions do, but what are their purpose? For schedules?
Also it states
"■ Foundation - wall foundations are members of the structural foundation category. The structural base
of a building that provides stability and rigidity"
This isn't true wall functions that are set to Foundation aren't part of the Foundation Category, they are still part of the wall category.
Getting more "conceptual" in our documentation
In response to user comments, the Autodesk BIM User Assistance Team at Autodesk has been working hard to add more overview information to the online help. In this example, the team has added information to the Walls chapter to help explain conceptually how walls work in Revit. Note, this is the...
Subscribe to Dennis Nelson’s Recent Activity