This is Farrar Richardson's Typepad Profile.
Join Typepad and start following Farrar Richardson's activity
Farrar Richardson
Recent Activity
I wish Dan and pgl would have more patience with slow witted folk like Roger Fox and me. I have to agree with Roger Fox that the author made very little effort to explain just how investment in government debt led to wider markets for private debt and thus to financing the industrial revolution.
My guess in that when the wealthy found that consuls paid better than investments in land. they probably became open to investing in paper that paid even better than consuls. We see this even now with investors spurning low yielding government debt in favor of stocks and higher yield corporate bonds. But Ventura and Voth could have explained this better.
'Debt Miracle: Why the Country that Borrowed the Most Industrialized First'
"When we consider the dangers of debt in today’s world, we should keep an eye on its potential benefits as well.": Debt miracle: Why the country that borrowed the most industrialized first, by Jaume Ventura and Hans-Joachim Voth, Vox EU: Towering debts, rapidly rising taxes, constant and expens...
I was under the impression that Peter Temin in his thoroughly researched, and well argued, The Jackson Economy (1969), had largely cleared Jackson of blame for the 1837 recession. It seems to me you have simply repeated the classical story of this recession, which as Temin showed is not supported by the facts,
The theories that you reiterate here were long accepted as plausible and probable causes of the recession, and they do make a better story. It is unfortunate, however, that a prestigious blog like this should risk perpetuating a historical myth, without even mentioning Temin's thorough scholarship which debunked it.
I hope you will issue a correction, or at least a clarification.
Crisis Chronicles: The Man on the Twenty-Dollar Bill and the Panic of 1837
Thomas Klitgaard and James Narron Correction: This post was updated on May 8 to correct the book title and spelling of the author’s name in the fifth paragraph. We regret the error. President Andrew Jackson was a "hard money" man. He saw specie—that is, gold and silver—as real money, an...
Farrar Richardson is now following The Typepad Team
Apr 1, 2015
Subscribe to Farrar Richardson’s Recent Activity