This is Harry Hobbes's Typepad Profile.
Join Typepad and start following Harry Hobbes's activity
Join Now!
Already a member? Sign In
Harry Hobbes
Broadwater County, Montana, USA
Someone on the other side of the boat...
Interests: Interested in the opinions of former operatives and knowledgeable players.
Recent Activity
Oopps! My bad... It appears Barr is associated with a different "Dominion;" not the voting machine firm. My apology to you and your readers...
Consider the Board of Director Nominees:
Thank you for this article. I also find it fascinating, albeit through comparing the conditions of the German (and their allied) POWs in the USA vis-à-vis the conditions on the European continent experienced by Allied POWs. "Daddy" went ashore with the Essex Scottish on RED BEACH at Dieppe, where he accumulated German steel fragments, some of which stayed with him through 2 1/2 years as a guest of the Wehrmacht and on to the grave. Some six decades ago, I asked him if he hated Germans. His immediate retort was an emphatic "NO, I hate Nazis; but I love the German people." Glad to learn that something similar was true in the USA at that time.
"To my knowledge, a typical full kit for combat infantry is often twice that weight. I personally know no one of any stature or sex who can carry 70% of their own body weight for 4 miles, let alone 12, and furthermore to be capable of fighting at the end of it."The "fighting load" (i.e., web gear/harness and accoutrements and immediate supplies: water, ammo, etc.) weighs in at about 25 lbs. More ammo ups the load weight from there. The "subsistence load" (the ruck sack and contents) for the typical U.S. Infantryman circa 1990 was anywhere from 50 to 70+ lbs., depending upon mission. Special Forces carried more. Then add weapon and kevlar. The young woman appears to have a moderate subsistence load, based upon what appears to be low-mass movement of the load as she moves (i.e., falters, falls, recovers); presumable in the 40 lb. range. I doubt she's carrying significantly more, as that would not be possible hunched over and hobbling along. (It appears her right hip is giving out.) Nonetheless, your observations about percentage of body weight are apposite. I and my squad typically humped 70 lb. subsistence loads (50% minimum body weight), and found that after a movement over hill and dale (say five+ miles through the bush) with subsistence load, we (straight-legged Infantry) were pretty much spent as a force, requiring time to recover. A "road march" would extend our distance before expenditure, as roads are by design, engineered to facilitate ease of travel. As much fun as it may be to be inclusive, I know from personal experience that weaker soldiers have to be supported and their "stuff" carried by the stronger. This is never good in a fighting force. Harry
Thank you Colonel for providing this excellent forum for insight...
Toggle Commented Jun 13, 2020 on SST at Sic Semper Tyrannis
Harry Hobbes is now following The Typepad Team
Jun 13, 2020