This is Ash Faulkner's Typepad Profile.
Join Typepad and start following Ash Faulkner's activity
Ash Faulkner
Recent Activity
Yes exactly Iain, my point is that they should do. The Scottish Parliament does, doesn't it? As for the issue of health and education I'm growing increasingly interested in vouchers, so my solution would probably devolve the powers the Scottish Parliament has to the counties, reform the electoral system within counties (give the power of recall, initiative, etc to make it truly accountable), and create complete independence for schools and hospitals (within regulation), so the state won't be the provider at any level. I pretty much agree with direct-democracy.co.uk
Of course an English Parliament would create a new layer of politicians, what else are you going to fill it with?
Englandism: Why the distaste for Englishness?
Englandism, "a regular irritant at Comment is Free and elsewhere", asks why being pro-England isn't more of a mainstream political position. Is it nasty? Is mentioning the English Votes for English Laws venturing into what both Jack Straw and Des Browne describe as dangerous territory where fe...
Brilliant article by John O'Sullivan on British culture. I completely agree with him, he's spot on.
Saturday 1st September 2007
9.15pm ToryDiary: Tories would force underperforming junior school pupils to retake final year 8.15pm ToryDiary: Davis tops shadow cabinet league table again with Warsi at bottom 3.15pm BritainAndAmerica: Britain looks back at early failures in Iraq but most Americans refuse to believe that th...
I think the reason English nationalism is looked down upon, but Scottish and Welsh is not, is because the English nationalists tend to be skin-headed, scary-looking, baseball-bat wielding individuals. It's also connected to football hooliganism (of course there's hooliganism in every team, but England is the most prominent British one). All of that characterisation is, I think, unfair, but there is a 'Keep England White' force within English nationalism that is absent from its Scottish or Welsh versions.
English Votes for English Matters is a bit iffy, and constitutionally messy. I think the answer to the West Lothian Question is to devolve most of the powers held by the Welsh Assembly or possibly the Scottish Parliament to the Counties. Historically we've always been a very localised country, and it's only in recent decades that centralisation has kicked in and caused the so-called nationalisation of responsibility. Subsidiarity (in a non-European sense :P) is a very good thing, and on the Continent is very popular where many things are localised. And of course we need look no further than the United States which has very good form on localism. So I think devolution of power to the counties is right in itself, will deliver more efficient services which respond to the people better and which satisfy them more, will weaken the central state, and will rebalance the WLQ without regionalising Britain or adding another layer of politicians in an English Parliament.
Englandism: Why the distaste for Englishness?
Englandism, "a regular irritant at Comment is Free and elsewhere", asks why being pro-England isn't more of a mainstream political position. Is it nasty? Is mentioning the English Votes for English Laws venturing into what both Jack Straw and Des Browne describe as dangerous territory where fe...
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/6958678.stm
Interesting, the unions are turning on Labour re: referendum.
Wednesday 22nd August 2007
7.15pm ToryDiary: The next ConservativeHome readers' survey 7.15pm Seats and candidates: Spencer Pitfield adopted for Penistone and Stocksbridge 5.15pm LondonMayor: Who will pay for the primary process? >> BBC Online is reporting that CCHQ has retracted an apology to one of the hospitals identif...
Absolutely spot on. I completely agree.
Nick Wood: Cameron must tackle the Brownite glacier that threatens to engulf him (and then give voters some reasons to vote Conservative)
Former Times journalist Nick Wood was a media adviser to Conservative leaders William Hague and Iain Duncan Smith. He now runs Media Intelligence Partners. Politicians face two key imperatives – to be right and to be popular. David Cameron’s biggest mistake has been to elevate popularity over ...
Jason, what is all this 'if Britain had used PR'? If Britain had a presidential democracy, if Britain had timetabled general elections, if Britain forgot there was an election on...
We (thankfully) didn't use PR. The point still stands that Thatcher did not win because the left was divided, she won because the left had failed. Her landslide majorities were certainy ensured by the divided left, but I think Labour had been discredited enough to ensure a Thatcher victory - '83 particularly being in the positive shadow of the Falklands victory.
Scott Kelly: When there is consensus there is Labour Government
Scott lectures for New York University in London. Fifty years ago last month, in one of his most notable speeches, the then Prime Minister Harold Macmillan proclaimed ‘most of our people have never had it so good’ and in many ways he was right. The Macmillan era saw the birth of a new consumer ...
I think it is fair to say that Redwood just owned Toynbee.
Wednesday 15th August 2007
11.30am update - Alan Duncan MP on YourPlatform: Gordon's many failures ToryDiary: David Cameron to put healthcare at the heart of his fightback In five years Transport for London has consumed £12 billion in subsidy but £8 billion of this has been wasted supporting TfL's bloated cost base. ...
It's rich for Roy Hattersley to be criticising Boris for buffoonery.
Monday 13th August 2007
3.30pm BritainAndAmerica: Is America turning left? and Join BritainAndAmerica's new Facebook group 11.30am ToryDiary: Scottish Tories join Labour and LibDems to oppose referendum on independence ToryDiary: Marland criticises the critics Platform: Daniel Kawczynski MP rebuffs Denis MacShane's Obs...
Shaun Bailey is absolutely brilliant. Put this guy in the Home Office, please!
Sunday 12th August 2007
8.15pm ToryDiary: Damian Green proposes action against forced marriages Edward McMillan-Scott MEP on Platform: Why we should boycott Beijing Graeme Archer's Diary: Why do Conservatives love George Orwell so much? ToryDiary: Redwood urges bonfire of regulations Gordon Brown orders all consti...
'3G Conservatism' sounds like opportunism plus social democracy. Conservatism really should be neither of these things.
This is a real problem, and it has bugged our distinguished predecessors in equal measure. Just what is conservatism? I really think we've spent too long thinking it is simple classical liberalism. Liberty is important to conservatism, but it surely is not the only thing?
I think until we can decide just what conservatism is, we're always going to have trouble deciding what direction to go in - and it's important we have one, we should not simply be reactionary.
Jack Perschke: The search for 3G conservatism
Cllr Jack Perschke is a Conservative Councillor at Runnymede Borough Council. An ex-army officer and aid worker, he is currently studying MSc Sustainability and Management at Royal Holloway University of London. Do you remember the world before mobile phones? When plans had to be stuck to, t...
"We have an ICC: why are the Junta members and other Burmese criminals not formed up there?"
Precisely because we have an ICC. Multilateralism (which effectively means unilateralism except by the UN) just doesn't work. If you have law, you need an enforcer.
Ben Rogers: A tribute to Burma's brave people
Benedict Rogers is a human rights activist specialising in South Asia. He works for the human rights organisation Christian Solidarity Worldwide and serves as Deputy Chairman of the Conservative Party Human Rights Commission. He has visited Burma and its border areas 18 times, and is the author ...
I agree entirely. The vast majority of politicians sound dull and boring, and are consequently thought of as dispassionate.
Those MPs that I can think of with any particular oratory skill are Galloway, Hague, Paisley...and that's all I can really think of.
Some people, perhaps most, just aren't naturally outspoken and flamboyant in the way you need to be to be a good orator. I'm not sure I agree about Thatcher as a great orator, to be honest. She got much better as the years went by, but I'd never say she was particularly amazing. She had a very distinctive and quite powerful voice though, which was helpful.
I think people must be careful about not waving their arms around *too* much, for fear of becoming almost Hitleresque. But certainly politicians should show more passion in what they say - though as I've said before, passion comes from honesty and conviction, which are two other qualities most are in short supply of these days.
What we don't need, though, is pause-for-effect politicians.
Clare Foges: Antiseptic oratory
Clare Foges, a Conservative researcher and activist, laments the death of passionate political oratory. Friends, Readers, Conservatives: oratory is dying. Rhetoric is always in decline; the Romans feared it had died with Cicero. But it is undeniable that in recent history we have witnessed...
A weak case. A war's brutality is not measured by it's time. In any case, the comparison is completely misleading: the World Wars were wars. It took the time it took years to defeat the enemy: in Iraq and Afghanistan, we removed our opponents with relative ease. The problem is keeping it under control, which is entirely different to war.
If Greg Hands wanted to extend his World War analogy further, he'd realise that following the war, we occupied Germany for many years. Indeed, there are British troops stationed in Germany even today. To ensure democracy took strength in Germany took longer than we have been in Iraq or Afghanistan. He's confusing the initial war and it's aftermath; in WWII, the war took five to six years, the aftermath took longer. We are not at war with Iraq, we are there on the request of the Iraqi government.
Oh, and the Iran-Iraq War was the longest conflict of the twentieth century, I believe.
Greg Hands MP: War in Iraq is now longer than the Great War; the conflict in Afghanistan longer even than World War Two
Greg Hands is MP for Hammersmith and Fulham. Last month, our armed forces reached two unlikely milestones. On 12th June, after 2,074 days, the war in Afghanistan overtook World War Two in length. On 27th June, after 1,560 days, the war in Iraq overtook World War One in length. Only seven year...
Funny article on David Davies here: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/6243803.stm
Thursday 19th July 2007
CLICK HERE FOR LIVE BY-ELECTION BLOG 10.30pm news update: BBC is reporting that there will be no charges in cash-for-honours Interviews: Any questions for Matthew d'Ancona and Warwick Lightfoot answers your questions Columnists: Louise Bagshawe: Protect women and children – reform the judici...
Article Thirteen of the Covenant of Hamas:
Initiatives, and so-called peaceful solutions and international conferences, are in contradiction to the principles of the Islamic Resistance Movement. Abusing any part of Palestine is abuse directed against part of religion. Nationalism of the Islamic Resistance Movement is part of its religion. Its members have been fed on that. For the sake of hoisting the banner of Allah over their homeland they fight. "Allah will be prominent, but most people do not know."
Now and then the call goes out for the convening of an international conference to look for ways of solving the (Palestinian) question. Some accept, others reject the idea, for this or other reason, with one stipulation or more for consent to convening the conference and participating in it. Knowing the parties constituting the conference, their past and present attitudes towards Moslem problems, the Islamic Resistance Movement does not consider these conferences capable of realising the demands, restoring the rights or doing justice to the oppressed. These conferences are only ways of setting the infidels in the land of the Moslems as arbitrators. When did the infidels do justice to the believers?
"But the Jews will not be pleased with thee, neither the Christians, until thou follow their religion; say, The direction of Allah is the true direction. And verily if thou follow their desires, after the knowledge which hath been given thee, thou shalt find no patron or protector against Allah." (The Cow - verse 120).
There is no solution for the Palestinian question except through Jihad. Initiatives, proposals and international conferences are all a waste of time and vain endeavors. The Palestinian people know better than to consent to having their future, rights and fate toyed with. As is said in the honourable Hadith:
"The people of Syria are Allah's lash in His land. He wreaks His vengeance through them against whomsoever He wishes among His slaves. It is unthinkable that those who are double-faced among them should prosper over the faithful. They will certainly die out of grief and desperation."
Michael Ancram MP: Why we should be talking to Hamas
Michael Ancram, MP for Devizes and founder of the Global Strategy Forum, argues that as Hamas isn't going to go away we should negotiate with them sooner rather than later. The whole question of the West engaging with Hamas in the Middle East has come very much to the fore with the release of ...
I wonder what the relationship with Cameron will be like. Will we look back on him as the best Conservative Prime Minister of the twenty-first century (;)), or as another in a long line of failures? Or as a medicore premier? What does the future hold.
Graeme Archer: How well have we got on with our ex-leaders?
Graeme A rcher, a blogger and activist in Hackney, reflects on the emotional wrench with which Tony Blair leaves office and reflects on our own history of relationships with Conservative Party leaders. How do you get on with your ex? Something most of us have to struggle with at one time or an...
"One more thought. Does this make Ted Heath the minger you pulled after a few too many beers who never forgave you for leading her on then running a mile when you saw who her in the cold light of day?"
Hahahaha, brilliant.
A funny and insightful article. You're right about the challenges of today.
Graeme Archer: How well have we got on with our ex-leaders?
Graeme A rcher, a blogger and activist in Hackney, reflects on the emotional wrench with which Tony Blair leaves office and reflects on our own history of relationships with Conservative Party leaders. How do you get on with your ex? Something most of us have to struggle with at one time or an...
Cherie to challenge smoking ban: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/6229490.stm
Friday 22nd June 2007
Evening ToryDiary: EU summit latest 5pm Seats and candidates: Zac wins Sainsbury's referendum 4.45pm ToryDiary: The return of 'Good week, bad week' PICK OF THE WEB Robin Millar, in the tradition of Sir Isaac Newton, is attempting to sum up local government in three laws Graeme Archer reviews ...
"I seem to remember that Heseltine was behind the helicopters must be built in Europe - his version of Westland - before he flounced out of the cabinet, but he reappeared and was visible during the demise of Maggie; I am informed that Hestletine was the inspiration for the Dome
(a fiasco); In my opinion he is a EU fanatic."
Dontmakemelaugh, I very much dislike Heseltine...but what the hell has any of that got to do with elected mayors?
Talk about ad hominem...
Saturday 16th June 2007
8pm ToryDiary: The pollsters on polling 3 ToryDiary: Public meetings and online forums to discuss party policy YourPlatform: Brooks Newmark MP defends the private equity industry STAND UP, SPEAK UP "David Cameron, the Conservative Party leader, has pledged an unprecedented change in policy mak...
Great speech from Lady Thatcher via radio to Falkland Islanders and the Armed Forces: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/6748125.stm
Text of speech here: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/6747849.stm
Wednesday 13th June 2007
5:30pm ToryDiary: A noble, but mercifully short, national struggle 5PM PICK OF THE WEB The Coffee House has been bustling today with posts on Brown's new Head of Domestic Policy and Strategy, Blair's penultimate PMQs, as well as Matthew D'Ancona (and Stephen Pollard) fretting about joining Fac...
Jailhouselayer, he really said that? :| :O
Tuesday 12th June 2007
4PM PICK OF THE WEB James Cleverly critisises attempts to legislate against breastfeeding in public ToryRadio is bemused at Tony Blair complaining about the media Peter Hitchens asks if democracy the same as freedom in his column, a theme picked up by this website Richard Spring MP describes th...
Jailhouselayer, he really said that? :| O
Tuesday 12th June 2007
4PM PICK OF THE WEB James Cleverly critisises attempts to legislate against breastfeeding in public ToryRadio is bemused at Tony Blair complaining about the media Peter Hitchens asks if democracy the same as freedom in his column, a theme picked up by this website Richard Spring MP describes th...
I've always found it ironic that those who claim to be egalitarians are the ones who always slot people into little social groups. Racism is alive and well - and it always will be as long as people can't look beyond skin colour, as the Labour Party clearly can't.
Alex Fisher: The sinister side to Labour's equality drive
Alex, a student and Vice Chairman of Bury Conservative Future, comments on the relaunch of the Black Socialist Society. "A group of right-wing Tory MPs today announced the founding of the White Conservative Society. Their move, which was immediately criticised by those on the centre and left...
"Anthony Steen, Tory MP for Totnes should be deselected if he hasn't already said he's retiring. His comments about "the hanicapped" on the BBC news brought the party into disrepute.
He's a silly man !"
His constituency is next door to mine. He's very locally popular - he's been the MP for over twenty years. He should not be deselected because of one foolish action. Talk about knee-jerk...
Saturday 2nd June 2007
1pm ToryDiary: The Conservative Party must unite behind the best leader it has had in years says The Daily Mail ToryDiary: How will Andy Coulson do? Platform: Liam Fox: lessons from the Singaporean Prime Minister and the US Defence Secretary Interviews: Samuel Coates answers your questions GRAM...
Denis is right, as long as we stick to an open-ended commitment to "ever closer union" there will always be internal fiddling going on. Europe needs to define itself at home before it can do so abroad.
Gates sounds good, and it seems an interesting conference. Keep up the diary.
Liam Fox: Lessons from the Singaporean Prime Minister and the US Defence Secretary
This is the second part of a diary that Liam Fox, Shadow Defence Secretary, is writing from Singapore. The opening speech was given by the Prime Minister of Singapore, Lee Hsein Loong. He praised the US commitment to the region and was reassuring about China (more an economic threat to the pow...
More...
Subscribe to Ash Faulkner’s Recent Activity