This is Pipertom's Typepad Profile.
Join Typepad and start following Pipertom's activity
Join Now!
Already a member? Sign In
Pipertom
Recent Activity
Perhaps that Rothbard quote was taken out of context. In isolation, it makes no sense -- no libertarian sense, anyway. Mr. Dillow comes close in his point 1 (gov lacks info) and in point 6 (legislating morality), but still misses the essence of the libertarian objection. Even if Gov could identify Deserving Poor (ignoring how subjective that might be), it is still both wrong and counterproductive to use violence to collect goodies for them. Libertarian goverment thus has no need to distinguish deserving from undeserving, since it won't be giving goodies to either. The rest of Dillow's points are pretty lame. Number 5 (reduce competition for jobs) is particularly Keynesian (and by "Keynesian", I mean limp-brained). I note that we can reduce competition for jobs by breaking all the windows, too.
Pipertom is now following The Typepad Team
Oct 27, 2012